Матильда О’Доннелл Макелрой — Розуэллское интервью 1947 года с инопланетянином

I was reading this book and thought I’d looks up some criticisms and came across this:

Red Flags: from Amazon review:

I was almost convinced this book was telling the truth, so I’m giving it five stars for that reason, and it has also opened my mind to a lot of concepts I would have been closed to before like astral projection and various fringe theories. The reason I think the book is fiction/made-up is for the following reasons:

1. The author uses some of the same vocabulary that he used in his previous book, The Oz Factor. Examples: «immoral spiritual beings», «vested interest».

2. The nurse was promoted to Senior Master Sergeant in 1947, but that rank wasn’t created until 1958.

3. Many ISBEs have already lived multiple lives on Earth implying that a relatively small number of ISBEs are being recycled, but the population growth on Earth would suggest that there are billions of ISBEs. Either there are billions of ISBEs and none of them have reincarnated yet, or there is a small number of ISBEs that have been reincarnated multiple times, but that would mean not every one of the 8 billion humans on Earth is an ISBE like the author states. This is a contradiction.

4. The author was a Scientologist long before he wrote Alien Interview.

I think it’s an interesting work, fiction or not, some of which rings true to my own findings in the occult, the stuff about souls etc. However, the stuff about history, wars, and technology I’m not so sure about.

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2021/02/roswell-and-matilda-odonnell-macelroy.html?m=1

Hoax from 15 20 years ago. Even the author admitted he didnt believe it on the paracast podcast back in the day